简介：InthiscollectionofRenminUniversityLawReview,thecriticismfrommycolleagueProfessorHuangXiangonmyworksOldCountryinNewFate:ClassicalConfucianPoliticalPhilosophyunderAncientandModernChineseandWesternReferenceispublished,togetherwiththeresponsefromProfessorLinMingzhaoofDepartmentofPhilosophy,TaiwanUniversity.ThefocusofthediscussionishowtounderstandConfucianism,andhowtotreattherelationshipbetweenmetaphysicsandpoliticalphilosophy,etc..Whatistherelationshipbetweenthisdiscussionandlaw?Iwouldexplainbelowandrespondtothecriticismtwoprofessorsbriefly.

简介：ItisnodoubtthatNewMissionofanOldState,BaiTongDong'srecentwork,ismoreremarkablethanmanycurrentresearchresultsincomparativestudiesofConfucianpoliticalphilosophy.IthasconductedinsightfulandinspirationalcomparisonandanalysisontherelationshipbetweenConfucianpoliticsanddomesticsociety.Theauthorisapprovedofmostofanalysisdetailsandconclusionsandhasnodoubtonitsresearchvalue.

简介：ThispapermainlycommentsMetaphysicsandThinningTheoryintheComparativeStudyofConfucianPoliticalPhilosophy-DiscussiononTwoProblemsinNewTheoryofOldCountrybyHuangXiang[1].BecauseHuangXiang'spaperisthecommentontheBaiTongdong'sbookOldCountryinNewFate:ClassicalConfucianPoliticalPhilosophyunderAncientandModernChineseandWesternReference,thediscussioninthispaperrelatestoHuangXiang'sreadingandunderstandingofBaiTongdong'sworks,andrelevantargumentofTongdong'sbook.